-
Arguments for and against codifying the UK constitution
... were turned into laws, leading to a rise in concerns over the incapability of parliament in limiting the powers of the executive and acting as a check on its powers. It can be argued that the main reason is fusion ...
-
Assess the constitutional impact of the decision of the House of Lords in the GCHQ case (Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service (1985))
... Lords that royal prerogative was in fact subject to judicial review, for reasons which I shall outline later. The minister's decision-making process was also deemed as unfair, mainly because of the lack of consultation with the staff, but overall the ...
-
Australia's need to change its constitution.
... Dawson continued on to say, "The continuing legal authority of our constitution derives from its original enactment at Westminster and subsequent retention by those empowered to amend it, which includes the Australian electors. But the latter derived their legal authority ...
-
‘UK central government has lost is power upwards to the European Union and other international organisations, and downwards to more localised institutions. This represents a major challenge to established means of constitutional accountabilityâ€(T
... that period, and government have greater chance of success in subsequent campaigns if they are able to hold onto public support. The role of maintaining executive accountability between elections is shared. Parliament, the courts and the media all play crucial ...
-
Barnett (Constitutional and administrative law 4th).
... whatsoever and those laws cannot be overridden by any person or body. Dicey defined Parliament as the 'Queen in Parliament', the sovereignty meaning all three institutions i.e. The Queen , the House of Commons, and the House of Lords.
Three basic ...
-
Before the issue of democracy within the EC can be considered, it needs to be defined. Democracy is, 'a form of government in which the people have a voice in the exercise of power
... a Constitution the following gives some insight into the function it should perform:
'the rules and practices that determine the composition and function of the organs of government in a state and regulate the relationship between the individual and the state'3
This ...
-
Bi polar sovereignty
... raises the possibility that judges can make law. This position is enhanced from the fact that judges may develop the common law. For example, in Shaw v Director of Public Prosecutions6 the House of Lords held that the publisher of ...
-
Can Torture Ever Be Morally Justified?
... a decision when the time comes that torture is not just acceptable, but necessary, for a greater good. This will be considered in much greater depth later on in the essay.
To give clarity to the argument, it shall be split ...
-
Compare and contrast written and unwritten constitutions. Which type of constitution do you favour?
... States of America is one of the countries that has a written constitution. This document is authoritative in the sense that it constitutes a 'higher' law, the highest of the land. It binds all political institutions in the country, including ...
-
Consider the Arguments For and Against Having a Written Constitution.
... of America a case Marbury v. Madison [1858] highlighted a situation where the government at the time passed a legislation which was contrary to the constitution. In this case the legislation was over-ruled by the courts as this was a ...
-
Consider the arguments for and against reform of the system of constitutional monarchy in the UK, and it's possible replacement by some other system.
... (PM) and cabinet?
Presently the sovereign has three main functions: attending public engagements, being symbolic and representative, and, more importantly, the sovereign has a constitutional function. The Queen's role, however, is limited to "the right to be consulted, the right to ...
-
Consider the view that the royal prerogative is insufficiently controlled by either Parliament or the judiciary.
... and responsibility are owed both to the Legislature and to the various parliamentary select committees.
The Separation of Powers doctrine requires the Legislature to assume the responsibility to influence, constrain, and demand justification for the actions of government and give them ...
-
Constitution of the United Kingdom - What options face the Commission on what to recommend about conventions, and which course of action would be preferable?
... fully written and codified constitution.
Our present constitution, although uncodified, is still in a sense, written, however it can be found in a number of different sources, which are constantly developing and evolving. Six main forms of out constitution may ...
-
Constitutional Law.
... which represent rules of key importance in the history of the constitution. There are also several acts that deal with the electoral system and the composition and functioning of parliament, such as the representation of the people Act, the Parliamentary ...
-
Constitutional Law: In the late twentieth century it is no longer possible for Parliament to fulfil
... accountability which becomes more entrenched with the fact that part of the executive resides in the House of Lords.
The Commons retrospective powers of scrutiny can be divided into two areas, those on the floor of the house and those not. ...
-
Constitutional problems 1789-1794.
... 28th September 1791 yet within a year the king had lost his throne and the constitution had been brushed aside.
The French revolution of 1789 did not set out to end the monarchy. It aimed to create a liberal constitutional government ...
-
Control orders and the Terrorism Acts
... declaration of incompatibility under s.3 Human Rights Act 1998.
The creation and introduction of Control Orders were a change from the detention without trial scheme, as it means that those under the control orders are subject to judicial review every twelve ...
-
control over royal prerogative
... case of domestic affairs it is: appointment and regulation of civil service (GSHQ case4), directing the deposition of the armed forces and commissioning its officers (Chandler v Director of Public Prosecutions [1964] AC 763), the prerogative of mercy (R v ...
-
CONVENTIONS
... continuous and mostly gradual and peaceful evolution. It also has an unbroken history development dating from 1066.
It is also necessary to understand issues such as, the conventions as a recognised source of the British Constitution. Constitutional conventions may not have ...
-
Conventions as a source of constitutional rules have been widely acknowledged.
... follows: 'By convention is meant a binding rule, a rule of behaviour accepted as obligatory by those concerned in the working of the constitution'. They are not obligatory but are in effect procedural agreements which all parties agree to. These ...
-
Council of Ministers
... the Merger Treaty created a single council of the European communities. This merged the special Council of Ministers the Communities and their Councils. In 1993 the Council of European Union with Maastricht Treaty reflected the wider change in name. This ...
-
Critically analyse if the European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms protect citizensâ€(TM) rights in the UK.
... which articles are qualified and looking at case law and journals to asses how effectively they protect our rights. Finally, the essay will conclude with how well the individual articles, and the European convention in its entirety, protect the rights ...
-
Critically review the following: (1) internal reviews and tribunals, (2) Internal complaints mechanisms and ombusmen, (3) regulation inside government
... consider how this function is performed by internal reviews and tribunals, internal complaints mechanisms and ombudsmen, and regulation inside government. It will analyse each of these mechanisms in turn, and in doing so take into account their effectiveness in providing ...
-
Define and analyse the principal amendments proposed by the new constitution for the EU.
... proposals concern the qualified majority voting system, the composition of the European Commission, the creation of the Union Minister for Foreign Affairs, citizenship and the incorporation of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the Union.
Qualified majority voting
Article 24 states ...
-
Describe the aims of the Founding Fathers of the American Constitution. How successful has the Constitution been in achieving these aims? May the Constitution be regarded as the culmination of early British liberalism?
... the restrictions of the government. The Second Continental Congress and its delegates from the thirteen colonies produced the first American constitution known as the Articles of Confederation. Having it executed from 1781 to 1788, it was not as effective as ...